Our Culture is Our Identity

“Healing resources for Aboriginal people are found in connecting with culture, nature, ceremony and other aspects of indigenous culture” (Goodwill & McCormick, 2012).  Everybody needs an identity which comes from our cultures.  First Peoples’ cultures have been actively assimilated and acculturated since colonization began.  In 1876, the government instituted the Indian Act which continues to be political legislation that governs every aspect of life for First Nations peoples.  Duncan Campbell Scott, the Deputy Superintendent of Indian Affairs stated, “I want to get rid of the Indian problem […] Our objective is to continue until there is not a single Indian in Canada that has not been absorbed into the body politic and there is no Indian question and no Indian Department” (Royal Commission Report on Aboriginal Peoples). The residential school system, the banning of ceremonies such as the potlatch, all assimilation processes have hinged on this piece of legislation.  Assimilation has caused severe psychological trauma to the Indigenous population because they were forced to take a culture and identity that was not their own.  “Historical trauma serves as a general backdrop for Native America experience and identity” (Ryback & Decker-Fitts, 2009).  The results of more than a hundred years of marginalization and acculturation of First Nations peoples and cultures have been the loss of identity. “The relentless subjugation of Aboriginal people and the discounting of their ideas have hurt those aboard the Aboriginal voyage of discovery into the inner space” (Ermine, 1995).  The loss of identity manifests itself as addictions, self-harm, and hopelessness which places people at risk for suicide. “…among the First Nations population rates of mental health problems such as suicide, depression, substance abuse, and domestic violence all seem to be significantly higher (than the general population)” (McCormick, 1996 emphasis mine)  For First Nations people, their identity is intertwined with their culture, language, and values.  The more immersed into their culture they become, the stronger their identity as First Nations people becomes.  Mental and emotional health is balanced for First Nations people when they have a strong identity that is deeply rooted in their culture, ceremonies, connection to the land, and language.  In this paper, I will discuss how First Nations identity comes from being rooted in their culture and ceremonies, and language.  Then I will discuss one cultural revitalization projects within the Vancouver area. 

Culture and Ceremonies

“Cultural resilience in their participants (Native Americans) was derived from the strength in family support systems, caring, communities, strong identities, spirituality, cultural values, worldview, ceremonies, and traditions.  Of these, spirituality was the core of Native people’s survival” (Grandbois & Sanders, 2009 emphasis mine).  Spirituality is at the center of all ceremonies, language, values, and culture.  This is because First Nations see everything as connected, and having meaning.  There is value and a spiritual quality to all aspects of life, that is, emotional, spiritual, physical, and mental aspects.  “Native Americans believe their healing practices and traditions operate in the context of relationship to four constructs – namely, spirituality (Creator, Mother Earth, Great Father); community (family, clan, tribe/nation);environment (daily life, nature, balance); and self (inner passions and peace, thoughts, and values)” (Portman & Garrett, 2006).  The four constructs are about encouraging the individual, and how that individual relates to the outer world. “The role of healing in traditional First Nations society has been not only to reaffirm cultural values but also to consider the individual in the context of the community” (McCormick, 1997).  The First Nations worldview sees everything as intertwined.  The individual is part of the larger community and works to serve that community as best they can.  The community carries the values, ceremonies, and culture that serve the best interests of the individual.  The community cannot exist without individuals, and individuals do better within a community context to support them.  All of the four constructs of the medicine wheel have spiritual meaning because spirituality is integral to the culture and ceremonies of First Nations people. “The Medicine Wheel philosophy of life is important to the inner dialogue because it identifies and describes the parts of the human make-up and shows how they are connected” (McCabe, 2008).

 For example, a smudging ceremony consists of using plant medicines such as sage, cedar, sweetgrass, and tobacco either all together or just sage, cedar or sweetgrass.   If the individual is smudging by themselves then they would go ahead and smudge themselves.  If the individual is smudging with other people then that person would offer the smudge to the other people first, and smudge themselves.  Then the offering would be used to acknowledge The Creator, Father Sky, Mother Earth, and the four directions, and the ancestors.  The person leading the smudging ceremony would then identify themselves to the ancestors, Creator, Father Sky, Mother Earth and the four directions and give them Thanks for the day and all the blessings given to them.  They can pray for the community, family and themselves.  Usually prayers for the self are done last because community and family members are important.  After the prayers are finished then the person would conclude the prayers with the phrase, “All My Relations” to acknowledge that everything, every one, every animal, insect, fish, and every plant and tree is related.   Within the context of the four aspects of the medicine wheel, the smudging ceremony is spiritual because it includes prayers and acknowledgement of universal powers.  It is physical because you burn sacred medicines (symbolizing earth the creatures and living beings on the earth, and connection to the land) in an abalone shell or shell from another sea creature (symbolizing the water and all the creatures that live in the water).  Smudging is a mental exercise because not only are you acknowledging spiritual powers but you also acknowledge yourself within the context of the entire universe, and culture.  The person leading the ceremony also needs to have the knowledge of how to do a proper smudging ceremony.  This includes the knowledge that when doing a smudging ceremony in a group, everybody in the group gets smudged first (placing importance on community and serving other people before ourselves), and the leader of the smudge smudges last.  We acknowledge problems, disasters, and also joys in the world, and the community. It also acknowledges illness, problems or good health within the family, and the problems and blessings of the individual.  Within the smudging ceremony everything is connected and it ultimately connects the individual into everything else in the universe.  This brings us back to how deeply First Nations identity is intertwined with their culture.  Every aspect of our culture contains the four constructs (spirituality, community, environment, and self), and the four aspects of the medicine wheel (spiritual, physical, emotional, mental).  Everything has meaning and value, without this cultural knowledge, First Nations people lose their identity more easily.  When people lose their identity, then they lose their hope and social problems become a community issue.  People’s confusion around identity and hopelessness for the future are the products of the government’s active assimilation policies. 

Language

“Indication that Aboriginal people were attaining knowledge of a very different nature and purpose from Western peoples is evident in Aboriginal language and culture” (Ermine, 1995).  Aboriginal languages, as with all languages, express the values of the culture.  As previously mentioned in this paper, all aspects of the medicine wheel, that is, spiritual, mental, physical, and emotional are intertwined in Aboriginal culture.  For example, “The Cree word mamatowisowin, describes the capability of tapping into the ‘life force’ as a means of procreation” (Ermine, 1995).  Ermine further explains the concept of mamatowisowin, “this energy manifests itself in all existence because all of life is connected, all of life is primarily connected with and accessed through the life force” (1995).  This Cree word is only one of the many First Nations languages that exist but it is a good example of how cultural values are expressed within language.  Brant Castellano describes mamatowisowin as, “the capacity to connect to the life force that makes anything and everything possible” (2000).  Brant Castellano’s description of this word emphasizes that the values being taught within this word is that everything is spiritual up to and including life itself.  The Ojibway word, Giibinenimidizomin means owning ourselves or being self-possessed.  Individuals who are self-possessed have no problem with their identity because they know exactly who they are and they are aware of their own limitations.  Goodwill and McCormick describe Giibinenimidizomin for First Nations people as happening when they are actively participating in ceremonies and community and can feel centered because of their involvement with their own culture (2012).  Giibinenimidizomin on a medicine wheel would be the following:  spiritual - visiting and learning from Elders in the community and attending ceremonies.  Mental - learning and retaining cultural knowledge such as how to use plant medicines, learning and speaking your language.  Emotional - attending community events and assisting your community when you can.  Building emotional bonds with other people in your family and community, and having a support system.  Physical, there are physical aspects in almost everything.  Cooking a traditional meal can be considered physical and also mental because of the knowledge of how to prepare the food.  Attending a sweatlodge ceremony can be spiritual, physical, mental and emotional.  First Nations languages carry the values of the culture.  The First Nations words mamatowisowin, and Giibinenimidizomin demonstrate the complexity and richness of their respective languages. 

Revitalization

Anderson Womens’ Healing Lodge Society

I was employed at Anderson Womens’ Healing Lodge Society for approximately two years.  Anderson Lodge is part of the Circle of Eagles Society and is located in Vancouver.  Circle of Eagles Lodge Society provides culturally appropriate services to Aboriginal men who have been federally incarcerated.  Jerry Adams, Executive Director of Circle of Eagles Lodge stated, “Many Aboriginal men (and women) have no connection to their roots.  Through various programs, from drumming to making button blankets, from hosting talking circles and arranging visits to a sweatlodge, we help forge those connections, allowing the brothers (and sisters) to discover who they are” (bchousing.org, emphasis mine)Anderson Lodge provides culturally appropriate services to its Aboriginal women who are homeless, fleeing an abusive relationship, and who have addictions issues.  In the past five years they have been given a contract from the Corrections Service of Canada to serve as a halfway house for federally incarcerated Aboriginal women.  Anderson Lodge’s programs include access to Elders; there is a sweatlodge on site, and drumming and singing.  There is an Elder on site at least two days per week.  The residents can assist the Elder by chopping wood for the sweatlodges, or they can just go and talk to the Elder.  The residents can also learn crafts such as beading or making dreamcatchers.  The Lodge has craft supplies on site so that the residents can feel free to make their own crafts without cost to the resident.  The Lodge also has a program called Bannock-on-the-run where the residents assist in making soup, bannock and sandwiches to distribute to the homeless in the Downtown Eastside.  Staff drives the residents to the Downtown Eastside to distribute the food.  The residents are given some money for participating in the Bannock-on-the-Run program.  It was enjoyable to observe the residents preparing the food all day and then get ready to distribute the food in the evening.  It never ceased to amaze me just how happy and excited the residents were to help the community in this way.  The therapeutic effect that this program has on people is so rewarding because it gave the residents a sense of accomplishment and community service.  The staff makes referrals to residents to outside sources from Addictions Counselling in a First Nations cultural environment to traditional language programs. 

Most of the women at the Lodge did not have the opportunity to learn about their culture as they were growing because they come from dysfunctional families, were part of the foster care system, or residential school survivors.  I would like to share some of the stories about the personal growth of the residents.  To protect the identity of the women, I have changed their names but not their stories. 

Eloise is from Katzie First Nations Reserve.  She came to Anderson Lodge after a 10-year incarceration at the Fraser Valley Institute.  When she first arrived she was quiet and mostly kept to herself.  While incarcerated, she had been active in the Native Sisterhood and many cultural activities.  After a few weeks of residing at the Lodge she began to attend sweatlodges regularly.  She spent a lot of time talking to the staff and the Elder.  Eloise began to participate in the Bannock-on-the-Run program.  Her enthusiasm for her community and culture encouraged the other residents to get involved.  After her first year of residing at the Lodge, she received a Grandmother Drum from the Elders.  She would often have Drumming and Singing circles with the other residents.  The last time that I saw Eloise was one year ago.  She has never broken any conditions of her parole and has remained in residence at the Lodge.  Throughout her stay, I observed that she became more self-possessed as the participation in cultural activities increased.  She was able to identify her feelings more readily, and express herself. 

Cherise is from Prince Rupert.  She was homeless and had addictions issues when she first arrived at Anderson Lodge.  She came straight from Cordova Detox to the Lodge.  She had a shy demeanor when she first arrived.  After being at the Lodge for a few months she began to open up to other people.  One of her favourite pastimes was doing crafts especially dreamcatchers.  She became so good at crafting dreamcatchers that she began to teach the new arrivals to the Lodge how to make them.  She also participated in the other cultural programs and activities at the Lodge.  She became an outgoing person by the end of her stay.  Her plan of action at the end of her residency was to return to her family in Prince Rupert.  She had been free from her addictions for at least six months by the time she returned to Prince Rupert.  She realized that being in Vancouver and away from her family was the reason that she had addictions issues. 

Conclusion

Aboriginal identity is rooted in being involved in our cultures, communities, ceremonies, and languages.  The more active Aboriginal people are in their culture and communities, the stronger their identity becomes.  In First Nations culture everything is connected and intertwined.  First Peoples languages reflect their worldview and values.  When the government began actively assimilating First Nations people, it deprived them of their cultural heritage.  The result has been generations of people who do not know their own culture and do not understand themselves.  Through revitalization programs such as Anderson Womens’ Healing Lodge Society people are now able to learn about their culture and the ceremonies.

Works Cited

Interview with Jerry Adams. (2011).Circle of Eagles Lodge in Vancouver Gives Residents New Lease on Life. Retrieved from: http://www.bchousing.org/Media/Stories/2011/11/22/3620_11112214

Brant Castellano, M. (2000). Updating Aboriginal Traditions of Knowledge.Indigenous Knowledge in Global Contexts: Multiple Readings of Our World.. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

Ermine, W. (1995).  First Nations Education in Canada: The Circle Unfolds. Vancouver: UBC Press

Goodwill, A.O., McCormick, R. (2012).  Giibinenimidizomin: Owning Ourselves – Critical Incidents in the Attainment of Aboriginal Identity. Canadian Journal of Counselling and Psychotherapy. Vol. 46 (1), 21-34.

Grandbois, D.M., Sanders, G. F.(2009) The Resilience of Native American Elders. Issues in Mental Health Nursing. Vol. 30, 569-580.

McCabe, G. (2008). Mind, body, emotions and spirit: reaching to the ancestors for healing. Counselling Psychology Quarterly, Vol. 21 (2), 143-152.

McCormick, R. (1996). Culturally Appropriate Means and Ends of Counselling as Described by the First Nations People of British Columbia. International Journal for the Advancement of Counselling, Vol. 18, 163-172.

McCormick, R. (1997). Healing through Interdependence: The Role of Connecting in First Nations Healing Practices. Canadian Journal of Counselling. Vol 31( 3).

Portman,T.A.A., Garrett, M.T. (2006). Native American Healing Traditions. International Journal of Disability, Development and Education. Vol. 53, 453-469.

Rybak, C., Decker-Fitts, A. (2009). Theory and Practice: Understanding Native American Healing Practices. Counselling Psychology Quarterly, Vol. 22 (3), 333-342.

The Real Crying Shame

Western society equates crying with weakness.  A person who cries at the work place is told to, "take a few minutes to pull themselves together", as though the crying person has completely lost touch with reality. The person crying is made to feel ashamed for expressing such deep emotions. Our society also believes that men should not cry at all.  A belief that I think is very damaging to the male psyche because it denies them the right to self-expression.

According to research, crying actually bonds people together.  http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/08/090824141045.htm  Crying is a release of built up tensions and emotions.  When we cry, we cry with our entire being - physically, emotionally, mentally, and spiritually.  Our body, mind and soul cry with us.  The real crying shame in our society is that crying is considered something that only weak women do. When in actual fact, when we cry, we are opening ourselves up to the support of other people. Here's an analogy from nature - when wolves howl it's because they're looking for their own kind.  They are searching for support for hunting and socialization.  In the same way, we can consider our crying to work in the same way as a wolf howl.  When we cry, it's a signal to other people that we're looking for their love and support.  

A few years ago I attended a First Nations memorial service for the husband of a good friend of mine.  One of the Elders talked about crying.  He said,"Crying allows us to gather strength.  Crying is for the strong."

Control Yourself

Their relationship had been intense for years.  It was clear to anybody who saw them together that they were in love.  They made each other laugh and sometimes cry.  But she grew tired of him because there was nothing new and exciting in their relationship.  It had become too comfortable. She knew she still loved him but it had become routine.  He knew that she had become bored.  But instead of bugging her about it and forcing the issue, he simply told her that he was willing to give her some space so that she could figure out what she wanted.  This intrigued her because her previous experiences in relationships had at times made her feel caged.  Now she was free to consider her needs and wants.  She decided that he was demonstrating true love in that he did not want to hold her where she did not want to be held.  She knew she would go away for awhile but she would return to him because of his generosity.

Sometimes relationships are like this.  Sometimes we just need to know that we will not be held captive by the people we hold near and dear.  It is at times of uncertainty that we know who truly cares about us.  When somebody we know is willing to place your happiness above their own selfish desires then we know that this is a person that we want in our lives for a long time.  It's so rare and refreshing not to have to fight for freedom in a relationship.  The question I pose today is are we trying to control the people in our lives? If so, then we need to consider what is missing in our lives that we find it necessary to control the people we love.  A long, introspective journey can shed light on this for us.  It occurs to me that it takes a lot more energy to try to control other people.  It takes less energy to figure out what our needs are and control ourselves.

Holistic Circulation

We had another Elder come and speak to my class this week.  This Elder is the Director of the Institute of Aboriginal Health.  He was fascinating to listen to, and I learned a lot from him.  The one thing that stood out for me was when he spoke about circulation in a holistic context. Naturally, for good health you need physical activity (physical circulation) but he expanded upon that and spoke about spiritual/emotional circulation, mental circulation, and social circulation.  He mostly emphasized spiritual circulation though, and it was at that moment that I realized that my life has become unbalanced.  I've realized this truth for a long time, but was procrastinating getting myself back into circulation.  I also realize that what he said was true that the more balance we have in our lives, the more healthy we become. 

There's much more to the Medicine Wheel then what I'm about to say so if you'd like to know more I would suggest going to the nearest Aboriginal Friendship Centre and speaking to an  Elder.  I will use my life as an example.  Right now I have mental circulation, that is to say that I am actively engaged in learning at university and elsewhere.  I have physical circulation because I aim to get to the gym between 3 - 4 times a week, and I'm active outside my gym time as well.  I have social circulation because I have many friends, and I actively meet up with them and socialize.  That leaves my neglected spiritual life.  I stopped smudging, and attending the sweatlodge because for about a year I was unable to do them.  Now, I've gotten out of practice of smudging, praying and taking time to sweat.  So, this morning I decided that enough was enough and I smudged for the first time in a long time.  I feel great right now.

The Medicine Wheel shows us where our life is not in balance.  I have set up my calendar with the medicine wheel in mind.  The activities are colour-coded so I can track the balance in my life.  I use the colour green for my spiritual/emotional activities and there's not enough green on my calendar right now.  Starting today, I'm going to change that and make more time for spiritual life.

Interconnectedness

Elder Larry Grant told the class that Indigenous food sources are becoming scarce. He said that First Nations’ diets were replaced with European food items.  Elder Grant specifically spoke about Camas Lilies and how important they were to Northwest Indigenous Nations.  He also mentioned that scientists have discovered that Camas Lily is a complex carbohydrate, and it takes a lot of energy for the body to convert the lily into sugar.  Complex carbohydrates are essential in the prevention of diabetes. Ingesting Camas Lily was replaced with the European potato.  The potato is not considered high in nutrients or a complex carbohydrate food.  The Camas Lily and other indigenous plant and animal species are being invaded by foreign flora and fauna. As a society, we need more concerted conservation efforts to keep a balance in our ecosystem.

I know from my volunteer work with Vancouver Parks that invasive species do put indigenous species at risk, both the flora and the fauna.  In fact, every year hundreds of volunteers assist park staff in identifying and removing invasive plant species such as Scotch Broom and Policeman’s Helmet. I also volunteer with The Western Painted Turtle Recovery Project, also a program through Vancouver Parks. I volunteer for two reasons: 1.) I believe in ecological restoration, and 2.) I am a member of the Turtle Clan and it’s very important to me that turtles be conserved.  The biologists and park staff are always educating the public about the threat to our ecosystem.  The threat is very real, and many indigenous plants and animals are on an endangered species list.  The Western Painted Turtle is considered a Red-Listed species, which means that it is endangered, and if we do not put conservation efforts in place then that species of turtle will become extinct.  The location I work at is Burnaby Lake Regional Park.  Burnaby Lake has about twenty-seven Western Painted Turtles living there.  It is one of the largest populations of Western Painted Turtles in British Columbia.  The Ministry of the Environment is considering breeding some of the turtles, hatching and nurturing the hatchlings so that they can help replenish some of the turtle populations around the province.   

Once indigenous flora and fauna become extinct we cannot get them back.  Once one species goes extinct then other species will follow because the ecosystem is interconnected, and one species relies on other species for survival.  When I lived in Ontario, I met an Ojibwa Healer knicknamed Sugar Bear, he told me that, “Bears and Turtles walk together.  If ever one ceases to exist then the other will cease to exist soon after.” Science has gained the understanding of the interconnectedness of our environment and species; First Nations communities have always understood interconnectedness to be true.

Time for Everything

I am starting to settle into a schedule for myself.  It's always a bit of struggle to find time for things once I start school.  This year I'm taking on a little more.  I am learning how to knit, I've joined a writer's group, next week I meet with a professor to discuss how I can assist her with her research, I'm a volunteer for Habitat for Humanity, and I still find time for myself, my school work, and my exercise classes.  I am busy but I'm also happy. I seem to be able to find time for everything that I want in my life.  I used to limit my activities because I thought that I couldn't fit it all in but I'm learning how to balance my life more.

Last night I went to an exercise class called Below the Belt, which is the same idea as the Buns of Steel videotapes were in the 80s.  It's all about the abdominals, back, legs, thighs, hips (you get the idea). I was sore this morning but I decided to go to kickboxing class anyway.  I told the Bootcamp Queen (instructor) that I was still sore from last night's class.  She told me that the best way to combat soreness is by doing  exercise because it helps get rid of the lactic acid build up in the muscles.  I hardly feel any soreness now, so I'm glad that I went.

To bring us back to why I started this blog in the first place, it's because I registered as a participant in a Breast Cancer Fundraiser for Spring 2013. I need to complete 6 exercise sessions (6 hours of exercise) in one day.  I am starting to feel prepared for this goal.  I can keep up with the classes now, do more intense exercise and my recovery time is not as long as it used to be.  Now I just need to remember to get on the fundraising portion of it.  I have some friends who say that they would like to sponsor me so I will be sending them a link telling them how they can donate to the cause. 

Stark Contrast

I am taking a fourth year course in First Nations Health.  The instructor recently asked us to journal our reflections about one of the readings.  I have decided to share that journal with you here.  Enjoy!

Stark Contrast

In this journal, I will be comparing my experience as a social service worker helping one of my clients experiencing appendicitis with the reading about Renee Smith dying as a result of a ruptured appendix.  I was shocked when I read that Renee died of complications from appendicitis.  Not too long ago, I helped save the life of a woman with appendicitis, whom I will refer to as Kathy. There are similarities between Renee and Kathy because both belonged to marginalized groups of people.  Renee was a First Nations girl, and Kathy was a homeless woman.  However, there is a stark contrast between how Renee was treated by medical personnel at the hospital and what happened to Kathy. 

In Renee’s case there had been neglect right from the time she entered the hospital the first time and the nurse gave her pain killers, and she was allowed to leave the hospital.  The next day when Renee came back to the hospital in worse condition, she was admitted with acute abdominal pains.  Renee was not started on IV medication even though she had not been able to retain any fluids due to vomiting and diarrhea. Renee died due to peritonitis from a ruptured appendix.  By contrast, Kathy came and spoke to me about not feeling well.  Kathy told me that she had been vomiting and felt nauseas.  Kathy was bent over in pain and I asked her about the pain.  She told me that it was going through to her back.  My biggest concern for Kathy was that she was dehydrating because she was vomiting.  I also knew from having experienced gall stone pain previously that the type of pain she was experiencing was indicative of something more serious than stomach flu.  After some talking, she finally gave me permission to call Emergency Services on her behalf.  The ambulance was there within fifteen minutes and they took her to St. Paul’s Hospital to be admitted.  The doctor ran some initial diagnostic tests on her and they discovered that she had appendicitis.  Kathy had her appendix removed within 10 hours of being admitted to the hospital. Kathy recovered quickly from her operation, and was back at the shelter within a few days.

My training is in social service work.  I am not trained in medicine, but even I understand the importance of replenishing lost body fluids.  I do not understand how doctors and nurses could overlook the fact that Renee was losing more body fluids than she was able to replenish.  The least that the medical staff could have done was to put her on IV medication while the diagnostics were being done.  In Kathy’s case, being put on IV was one of the first things the medical personnel did to help her.  In Renee’s case, the diagnostic testing such as an X-Ray was either delayed, or not even done as in the rectal exam to confirm the diagnosis of appendicitis (131).  Kathy was fortunate to have medical personnel who were attentive to her needs.  I think that Dr. Mills sums up well when she uses the following description at the Inquest, “She [Dr. Mills] criticized the treatment Renee had received and said that on a scale of one to ten, with “one” as the lowest, Renee’s care deserved a “two” and “reached the level of malpractice” (Speck, 131) [emphasis mine]. 

Equiarchy

I was having a really frustrating day when I saw this post on facebook.  I can't even begin to express my outrage at what he's said here.  I have heard a few uneducated boobs express the same notion.  I intend to demonstrate why such notions are not true. I contend the problem is not with feminism, but with absolute patriarchy. 

We don't need to go too far back in the law books to find a time when women were not even considered persons under the law. We also don't need to go too far back in history to find a time when women could not vote, could be beaten to death by their husbands (his property, his right), he could also kill his children. The husband was not accountable for this because his wife and children were considered his property to do with as he pleased. Recap: 1.)Women not considered persons under the law, 2.) Husband could kill wife and the children without justification.  Remember these laws came into effect under absolute patriarchy and it sounds pretty anti-family to me if you can kill family members and not have to answer for it. Abortion has been around since the dawn of time.  Abortion is not a new invention.  I won't even subject you to some of the horror stories (Victorian Era) of what some families would do to babies they could not afford to feed. Once you start seeing some historical facts, it is hardly fitting to label feminists as child killers when all along men have been killing their wives and families. And, of course, some feminists are Pro-Choice.  Let's not forget the fact that many men nowadays also see themselves as feminist because feminism is for gender equality (both men and women).

I am not thrilled by the ad hominem argument that feminism is equated with witchcraft. Both men and women are Wiccans. So, why is he just attacking women? When looking at history we can find examples of rich and powerful men belonging to their own secretive religious sects, such as the Freemasons, and similar organizations.  This does not even include the Gentleman Clubs.  At one time in history, respectable women did not go to pubs or taverns.   Every establishment was by men for men. Womens' lives revolved around the Church and the family. At certain points in history, when there were witchhunts, even being active in a church could not save you if you were accused.

Apparently, Feminism is about socialism and destroying capitalism.  The last time I read the Bible it didn't say anything in there about being against socialism and pro-capitalism.  It says nothing about either of them. Capitalism is not the be-all and end-all.  It's the economic system currently used but that could very well change at some point in the future.  The Barter System, The Trading System, & Feudal Systems changed into Capitalism.  Whose to say that Capitalism won't morph into something else in due time?

And, of course, the good old standby of labelling women as Lesbians when all other arguments fail.  It's really none of his concern how anybody else, man or woman, identifies as their sexual orientation.  But, once again, he's choosing to an ad hominem argument to attack women in general.  In particular, Lesbian women are the aim of his attack.  A person's sexual orientation is of no concern to me.  What I like to know about people is if they make sense when they talk (?) Are they kind, and compassionate? If you're going to judge somebody based upon their sexual orientation then I feel very sorry that you live such a narrow-minded and self-centered existence.

Long story, short - if you need to use fear-mongering tactics to try to persuade people to your way of thinking then your arguments are not that good to begin with.  The poster above uses fear-mongering, attacks women especially feminists (for no good reason), lacks historical accuracy and viewpoint which essential when one is talking about marginalized groups such as women.  I see a man who longs for absolute power through patriarchy.  A man who will attack one of the most marginalized groups of people in history and in the present, stomp on their rights, piss on Wiccans and on Socialists just to satisfy his greed for money.  The very core of his message is to save capitalism. The rest is labelling and fear-mongering. Save capitalism? Shit Dude, look around, capitalism doesn't need saving. Laws created under Absolute Patriarchy are the crux of most of the social problems our society has today.  We should not be trying to preserve Absolute Patriarchy, but combine it with Matriarchy.  The result of Patriarchy + Matriarchy=Equiarchy.  An equitable and fair system for all citizens.